Joe Iconis Christmas Extravaganza Returns to 54 Below for Its 15th Annual Holiday Run

The Joe Iconis Christmas Extravaganza is making its return to 54 Below this December, bringing back the long-running New York City holiday tradition for its 15th consecutive year. The show is scheduled for December 12–14, 2025, with two performances each night at 7 PM and 11 PM.

Written by Joe Iconis, known for Be More Chill, the production continues to be directed by John Simpkins and produced by Jennifer Ashley Tepper, maintaining the same creative leadership that has shaped the event’s identity over the years. Described as a mix of rock concert and theater piece, the holiday event promises new songs, returning favorites, and a cast of 50 performers.

This year’s lineup includes Annie Golden from Hair and Liz Lark Brown from White Girl in Danger, adding well-known talent to the already packed cast. Returning collaborators such as Gerard Canonico (Spring Awakening), Max Mendoza Crumm (Grease), Morgan Siobhan Green, Eric William Morris (King Kong), Jason SweetTooth Williams (Be More Chill), and Lauren Marcus (Be More Chill) are also confirmed to appear.

The roster features Aaron Clark Burstein, Sarah Cetrulo, Harrison Chad, Bill Coyne, Laura Dadap, Michaela DeJoseph, Giovanny Diaz de Leon, Katrina Rose Dideriksen, John El-Jor (We Live in Cairo), Seth Eliser (Saturday shows only), Badia Farha (Saturday and Sunday at 11 PM only), and Vince Fazzolari (7 PM shows only). Additional performers include Omar Garibay, Danielle Gimbal, Ian Kagey, Dennis Michael Keefe, Jaz Koft (11 PM shows only), Lorinda Lisitza, Kelly McIntyre, Devon Meddock, Jimin Moon, Jeremy Morse (7 PM shows only), Kevin Michael Murphy, Rob Rokicki (7 PM shows only), Mike Rosengarten, Jackie Sanders, Brooke Shapiro, Lena Skeele, Philip Jackson Smith, Brent Stranathan, Lilly Tobin, Vinnie Urdea, Jason Veasey (A Strange Loop), Tatiana Wechsler, and Jared Weiss.

The production also confirms more performers to be announced, keeping with the tradition of the show’s continually expanding ensemble. Fans can expect a combination of fresh material alongside the signature elements that audiences return for each year.

Choreography for the 2025 edition is handled by Christine O’Grady, bringing structure to the show’s energetic performance style. Costume design is led by Brendan McCann, ensuring the event’s signature bold and colorful holiday aesthetic remains intact.

The role of assistant director and environmental designer is filled by Max Friedman, contributing to the immersive and lively atmosphere the show is known for. This aligns with what 54 Below describes as part music event and part theatrical spectacle, which has been a hallmark of the Extravaganza.

Tickets and additional event details are available on the official 54 Below website at 54Below.org, where visitors can find seating options and performance specifics. More information about Joe Iconis and his upcoming projects can also be found on his official site at MrJoeIconis.com.

For longtime fans and new attendees, the 15th Annual Joe Iconis Christmas Extravaganza promises another year of high-energy performances, holiday-themed musical moments, and a full cast of iconic performers celebrating the season in a big, theatrical way.